So it has been a while since we posted, but the rationale was we’d wait till we had a working example of moving past push pins. This week we got our GeoIQ API working with the Google Maps API and have the first set of screen shots to show. One of the things we thought is really missing from web mapping applications, right now, is the ability to do geographic analysis. Even the ability to make basic decisions like – is location “A” better than location “B” is missing. With this first simple idea in mind we’ve built a quick mashup with Google Maps. We took our heat mapping API and integrated it with a split screen Google Maps viewer. That way you can look at two locations at the same time and compare them.

We wanted a fun data set to play around with and thought traffic congestion/delay would be interesting. The Bureau of Transportation Statistics (BTS) has a cool data set with average traffic delay for all the US highways available, so we threw that in. One of the problems with pushpins or polylines in Google Maps (and others) is there is no way to visualize what are the high value or low value pushpins. In this case, which road has high traffic delay and which roads have low traffic delay. We do this with a heat map (similar to Zillow, Google Adsense, etc.) that can be dynamically refactored as you zoom in/out (see previous post). We added to this heat map tool a concentration index – which gives you a score of the value (weight) of your pushpins and how closely they are located together. Once you have the score you can see if location “A” is better than location “B”. In this case is traffic delay more concentrated in location “A” or location “B”

A comparison of the concentration of traffic delay in San Francisco and Los Angeles

The GeoIQ API creates a heat map based on an index that measures the amount of traffic delay on the roads and how closely that road delay is located to other delayed roads. The higher the delay and the closer together the roads, the hotter the map and the higher the score. The score ranges between 0 and 1. If all the traffic delay and highways were concentrated at one single location the score would 1 and if there was no traffic delay the score would be 0. In the map above traffic delay for Los Angeles in .26 and for San Francisco it is .15, so if you believe the BTS data traffic, LA is about twice as bad as SF. Lets go east coast – NYC vs. DC.

A comparison of the concentration of traffic delay in New York and Washington DC

According to this score NYC is a little worse than DC. The cool thing about the technology is you can run these comparisons on the fly as you zoom in and out of the map. So – let’s compare two big traffic bottlenecks in DC to see which is worse the I-270 Spur or I-95 Mixing Bowl.

A comparison of the concentration of traffic delay at the I-270 Spur and the I-95 mixing bowl – both in Washington DC

The Spur looks to get the better of the Mixing Bowl. In the app you can do this with any data set or mash up multiple data sets to solve a variety of problems surround location decisions. We’ll have more to come so stay tuned if this looks interesting.

 

42 Responses to Heat Maps for Google Maps – (a.k.a GeoIQ mashup)

  1. DofAM says:

    Looks great, definitely a big increase in functionality over traditional GEarth mash-ups.

  2. Eric says:

    Very fun! When will there be a demo up that we can play with? I’d like to try testing some of my own locations.

  3. Hadley says:

    That looks like a really nice idea, but I think your pictures illustrate some of the problems with heatmaps – it’s very hard to convert that colour scale back to the original values. For example, comparing the spur and the mixing bowl, the spur has a lower value (0.16) but it looks like a brighter center point. I’d recommend experimenting with using other ways of representing the same data. For example, you could place points at each measurement location and then make the size of the point proportional to the amount of traffic (aka a bubble chart). This would also remove the uncertainty over whether an area has no traffic, or no measurements.

    I’m also not sure about your smoothing algorithm – it would be nice (but difficult) to take into account the actual geography of the roads, traffic density falls off abruptly on the sides of the road, not gradually!

  4. Sean Gorman says:

    Heat maps (map algebra – raster analysis) are one of the spatial tools you can use for geographic analysis of data. It does have its strengths and weaknesses, just like any other analytic. Although I do think we should clear up a little bit what those are.

    Sure you could drop proportional symbols on top of the map – it is not terribly hard to do, and we’ll probably throw it in for a later release. You have a nice review of the benefits of proportional symbols, but there is also some drawback that heatmaps do much better. Proportional symbols do not work very well for polyline data, but regardless it would tell you the same thing as the heat map – the ramps connecting the major arteries of the I-270 spur (according to BTS) do not have as much traffic. That said sometimes proportional symbols are a better choice for a map, and that is up to the user to decide. Let’s not forget before today there were zero choices for Google Maps.

    What you cannot get with proportional symbols is a score to compare two location. Secondly you cannot not integrate more than one variable to make a location decision. Thirdly they scale terribly – what happen when you try to draw 80,000 bubbles at the national level for the entire highway system. Lastly, you cannot do any of the fancy map algebra analytics like looking at temporal changes.

    To answer the last question – you can take into account distance with smoothing algorithm. Spatial mathematics (splining, kriging, kernel density) to make heat maps require that you set a distance threshold. We do this dynamically as you zoom in so

  5. Sean Gorman says:

    you get an increasing about of detail as you go. You can also set it yourself with a slide bar. Since it is a Gaussian distance decay function it will search out for attributed data as far as you tell it to. The result is a surface not a line. If we had geo-referenced data on different delays for different lanes you could see that, but BTS only has one figure for each road. The distance decay fade does not mean there is delay in the medians or on the shoulders it is just the way the mathematics works.

    You are of course free to use whatever tool you would like. We are just trying to make more tools available to the public so they pick the right one to solve the problem at hand.

    Re-reading this post also makes me realize we are really getting into the academic nitty gritty of analytics, and our whole goal was for users not have to deal with that level of detail to solve a problem. We are happy to explain how we do thing and the mathematics and rigor behind them at any point so feel free to ask.

  6. Heat Maps for Google Maps

    "So it has been a while since we posted, but the rationale was we ’d wait till we had a working example of moving past push pins. This week we got our GeoIQ API working with the Google Maps API and have the first set of screen shots to show."

  7. James Jones says:

    I think this was talked on eUNKNOWN and they talked how it is not 100 percent correct or how it would not be 100 percent correct or somthing like that.

  8. Jason D says:

    Uhhhh yeah… anyone who says the Spur is worse than the Mixing Bowl needs to have their head examined (or logic reprogrammed). Just a thought from someone who actually drives the area.

  9. [...] Heat Maps for Google Maps The GeoIQ API creates a heat map based on an index that measures the amount of traffic delay on the roads and how closely that road delay is located to other delayed roads. (tags: googlemaps maps mashup data database visualisation) [...]

  10. Prashanth says:

    Another thought that occured to me was the use of a time dimension.
    The use of a slider could provide you with the ability to “slide” across a timeperiod (a day, a week, perhaps more). The concentrations across a time scale would be of particular interest to people who are also trying to perform a trend analysis. Just my initial thought.
    Interesting approach -> can be applied to a whole gamut of GIS data; pollen, pollution levels, even by grocery stores to evaluate product sale.

  11. Stephen G says:

    Here’s a color-coded / thematic map integrated with Google Maps. Includes rollover / hover text.
    http://www.gmapsgis.com/examples/2004election.php

  12. True says:

    Good post: the only thing better that knowing, is knowing together.

  13. [...] Moving Past Push Pins » Blog Archive » Heat Maps for Google Maps – (a.k.a GeoIQ mashup) (tags: cool google Maps Googlemaps mashup heatmap visualization traffic) [...]

  14. [...] FortiusOne is about to release (with an API trial key) their GeoIQ API that works on top of the Google Maps API. GeoIQ should provide the geographic analysis facilities that Google Maps lacks. Their first idea has been to integrate their heat mapping API. In their blog, they provide an example of heat maps of traffic congestion based on the US Bureau of Transportation Statistics. [...]

  15. [...] "So it has been a while since we posted, but the rationale was we ’d wait till we had a working example of moving past push pins. This week we got our GeoIQ API working with the Google Maps API and have the first set of screen shots to show."read more | digg story [...]

  16. Philip Ganchev says:

    Awesome! Later, things like road conditions can be modeled more precisely. For example, a highway may be somewhat congested but still move faster than a small road. And the congestion may be only in one direction.

  17. Good post: the only thing better that knowing, is knowing together.

  18. [...] Another cool way to waste time: Heat Maps for Google Maps – (a.k.a GeoIQ mashup) [...]

  19. There’s one special secret Sale link on Amazon:

    http://tinyurl.com/2r7ldr

    [b]This is open every Friday and ONLY on Fridays! [/b]

    You can find very good discounts here, although some Fridays you can really get
    lucky and make off like an Amazon bandit – I´ve seen discounts there as low as 75%
    off sticker Price.

  20. Ken says:

    So zillow has a heat map, but it is a still shot of the market prices. Has anyone ever tried to apply the dimension of time to this, rendering a market price rate of change? For example… market trend over the past month, the past quarter, 6 months, year, 5 years, etc. If anyone knows how this could be done, PLEASE contact me. I am vitally hungry for this information!

  21. I was playing poker the other night with Tarot cards I got a full house and 4 people died — Steven Wright

  22. BradiGuns says:

    Hello
    Good news guys
    I here I with you
    http://cialis20mg.org

  23. Frezzoa says:

    Hello Men’s
    you must trasted

  24. TaferyPupki says:

    Hello
    stgdgedr
    restartos

  25. katie says:

    hi wats upimon a laptop and hi

  26. Cheap Flomax says:

    Prescription drugs without a prescription and generic medications. Canadian online medicine.
    http://canadian-online-medicine.com

  27. wateryahooya says:

    site google home green mail ibm

  28. Sounds crazy. I like the way you react to my adventures techniques I have a nice joke. What does a dog get when it finishes obedience school? A pet degree.

  29. TurboTad says:

    Do you know if there is any published library for generating these heat maps from a KML file? I’d love to be able to do some geo-visualization like this.

  30. de/numerics says:

    Now added to our newly released Google heatmap service…
    a PHP driver code example.

    Start at: diffent.com/heatmap

    Example in JavaScript also but can be driven from any HTTP POST driver.

  31. ????? says:

    The HeatMapAPI is an API that enables anyone to create their own heat maps. If you wish to use the HeatMapAPI the GeoChalkboard blog has a good tutorial on how to create a heat map with the API and Google Maps.

  32. that will help me in my stydy
    thanks alot

  33. reserve says:

    Wow, marvelous blog layout! How long have you been blogging for? you make blogging look easy. The overall look of your web site is magnificent, let alone the content!. Thanks For Your article about Heat Maps for Google Maps – (a.k.a GeoIQ mashup) | GeoIQ Blog .

  34. ApoppyDok says:

    Cruz said he never thought he ever would be able to be in a position to help a grieving family with any type of relief like that They’re a great family [url=http://www.cheaperjerseyschina.com/]Cheap Jerseys China[/url]
    they are really united right now at this time Martin, a 1,000-yard rusher in the first 10 games, has 106 in the past two Football was a miracle for Kitna If you can block up [url=http://www.cheaperjerseyschina.com/]Cheap Jerseys China[/url]
    have enough time for routes to develop we should be fine
    s campus “Anytime Jim Brown’s name is mentioned, it is big for me The same team that won just two games all of last season, is now winning with a rookie QB [url=http://www.cheaperjerseyschina.com/]Cheap NFL Jerseys From China[/url]
    names like TFor a moment Kitna is silents because I went hereCerullo said hits for cash started with Williams telling the staff that “Sean kind of put him in charge of bringing back a swagger to the defense

  35. Louis says:

    Amazing! Its truly awesome post, I have got much clear idea concerning from this piece of writing.

  36. Have you ever thought about creating an e-book or guest authoring on other sites?
    I have a blog based upon on the same topics you
    discuss and would really like to have you share some stories/information.

    I know my readers would appreciate your work. If you are even remotely interested, feel free to send
    me an email.

  37. Hi there! Do you know if they make any plugins to assist with SEO?

    I’m trying to get my blog to rank for some targeted keywords but I’m not seeing very good results.

    If you know of any please share. Appreciate it!